By Hillary Busis
October 16, 2012 at 01:34 PM EDT

Jennifer Aniston will always be America’s sweetheart. Just look at the way her face scrunches up in glee when Chelsea Handler asks her about her engagement to Justin Theroux — it’s downright adorable. And how many 43-year-old women can legitimately claim to be adorable? When she gets teary, you just want to give her a hug, then invite her over to watch season 3 of Friends with you. Even tart-tongued Handler broke character to celebrate her pal last night: “He’s the greatest guy ever, and you guys make the greatest couple ever, and I’m so happy for you too.” So are we! Hooray! Let’s get yogurt!!

Of course, the host did also call Jen out for tending to wear shirts that show off her nipples… so maybe the praise party only goes so far. Check out both moments in the videos below. And for the record — yeah, you can kinda see some headlights in the second clip.

Be honest, guys: You watched the second clip first, didn’t you?

Read more:

MC Gwyneth Paltrow and DJ Jazzy Cameron Diaz rap for Chelsea Handler — VIDEO

Chelsea Handler writing a book called ’50 Shades of Chartreuse’

Jennifer Aniston pregnant with triplets (in new commercial) — VIDEO