Hudson Michele Glee
Credit: Adam Rose/Fox

The season premiere of the new-formula Glee (“Now with extra added smirks!”) had an advance push from the preview clips Fox released of Kate Hudson going hard-body Bob Fosse on us; if she didn’t quite inspire the curiosity Gwyneth Paltrow initially did (after all, the stakes were greater: Would Gwynnie Get Down?) (answer: affirmative), Hudson was certainly more of a draw than, say, John Stamos was. Plus, Hudson’s character NYADA dance teacher Cassandra July was there to do what some of us take, yes, glee in witnessing: Anyone who attempts to demolish the Kryptonite-hard ego of Lea Michele’s Rachel.

The episode titled “The New Rachel” was lumpy-paced and uneven, with the irritations outnumbering the pleasures, but those pleasures were significant, and hopeful for the season as it moves forward. Since I brought up the subject: Welcome, Melissa Benoist; your Marley Rose, even beneath that sad, droopy newsboy cap, is a very good addition to the show and you took quiet command of every scene you were in. In addition to being able to smile more sincerely than 99% of your new cast-mates (I do believe Kurt is your only competition there), Marley’s edited-side-by-side “duet” with Rachel blew the latter off the screen for its rare-for-this-series unmannered energy. And that’s really saying something when the song you’re pushing is Billy Joel’s bombastically self-absorbed “New York State of Mind.”

This episode had to accomplish a number of things: prove to us that it could juggle old and new characters in two locations, New York and Ohio; give iTunes its profit with a cover of “the song of the summer ‘Call Me Maybe'”; make sure Sue Sylvester had just enough face-time to cuddle her baby and out-do Hudson’s July for meanness.

So far, Becca Tobin is being encouraged to be excessively smirky even by Glee standards; she ought to be allowed to dial it back a little if the show wants her Kitty to be more than a robotic sourpuss.

Hello, Whoopi Goldberg.

As for Hudson’s guest arc, her Cassandra has already done what she was brought in to do — show off the sculpture; move with nicely edited conviction; tell Rachel she has a “stuck-up little bitch attitude” and “you suck.” In short, she fulfills the now time-honored Glee convention of being a character who says lots of viciously cruel things, cutting until other characters bleed emotionally, so that other subplots can literally sing the praises of tolerance, love, and anti-bullying* (*trademark, as of last night, Demi Lovato/The X Factor). Only five more episodes to go, Cassandra! Enough to let her ostentatious drinking problem to blossom further and, I sincerely hope, yield a smartly framed, non-smirk argument for AA: It’s the least and best preachment Glee could offer.

But I’ll take a decent Games of Thrones throwaway joke and the ongoing promise of a luminous Marley as guarded good signs that Glee might be willing to slither past its self-imposed limitations for a few episodes into its new season.

What’d you think of the premiere?

Twitter: @kentucker

Episode Recaps

The fourth season of Glee was full of ups and downs, but one consistent bright spot was Lea Michele's Rachel Berry, who stretched her wings…


Jane Lynch, Lea Michele, and high school anxiety star in Fox’s campy musical.

  • TV Show
  • 6
  • Fox
stream service