By Hillary Busis
August 14, 2012 at 04:20 PM EDT
Pacific Coast News

PETA vice president Dan Mathews thinks Lady Gaga is a monster — and not the good, Gaga-approved kind.

For years, the animal rights watchdog group has been firmly in Gaga’s corner. It applauded the pop star in 2009 for wearing a coat made out of Kermit the Frog carcasses rather than real animals, proudly citing her rationale for the outfit: “I really loved this one in particular because I thought it was commentary on not wearing fur, ’cause I hate fur and I don’t wear fur,” she said.

But lately, Gaga’s been photographed wearing apparel that looks suspiciously like dead animals — both on the street and in a poster for Robert Rodriguez’s upcoming Machete Kills. And naturally, her old boosters aren’t too stoked about this development. As Mathews writes, in typically understated PETA fashion:

What happened? Are your stylists telling you that it’s fake, or are you a turncoat?  Many gays are animal advocates because we recognize that the same arrogance and indifference that some have toward animal suffering has at times been directed toward us personally because of our orientation. PETA has long participated in Pride events around the country, and just last week, we helped lead protests against Chick-fil-A. But by wearing those dumb furs in a heat wave, you’re making yourself a target just like the mindless Kim Kardashian.

Though Gaga must have been impressed by the topicality of Mathews’ letter — references to Chick-fil-A and a Kardashian? — she hasn’t yet responded directly to his accusations. Instead, the poker-faced singer simply tweeted a coy retort:

For those press and such who are writing about whether or not my fur is actually real, please don’t forget to credit the designer HERMES. Thank You! LOVE, gaga

(This post brought to you by Hermes.)

Read more:

Lady Gaga looks perfectly ordinary on the cover of ‘Vogue’, no one claimed — PHOTO

Lady Gaga announces new album title. It’s…

Is PETA Pushing Its ‘Luck’ in Hollywood?