July 27, 2012 at 09:08 PM EDT

Every season there’s one show that critics start piling on long before it premieres. This round it’s ABC’s The Neighbors, the aliens-next-door sitcom that has inspired the entertainment industry and viewers to exclaim a collective “WTF?!”

I suspect viewers will rate a few other new broadcast comedies this fall as far worse (such as ABC’s Malibu Country*). The Neighbors is not without cleverness, and sure doesn’t lack for ambition. I’ve found a few defensive-sounding fans of the pilot out there (not me, but others). The whole premise is just so … so … goofy, and such a throwback to old school sitcoms like 3rd Rock from the Sun and Alf, that it’s more jarring as a concept than it is terrible as a show (if that make sense). Naturally, ABC entertainment president Paul Lee is one of the fans.

“I love The Neighbors,” he told critics at their semi-annual press tour in Beverly Hills. “I know there’s some issues in the room about the high-concept nature of the show.”

ABC originally planned to air The Neighbors at 9:30 p.m. on Wednesday nights after its biggest comedy, Modern Family. But after a couple months of industry disbelief about that strategy, ABC recently decided to give the show a Modern Family lead-in after its premiere, then move the show  to an hour earlier.

“I thought 8:30 p.m. suited the show better, ” Lee said. “I did want to protect it … there’s so much pressure [to perform] after Modern Family … I’m much more comfortable where it is.”

For those who haven’t seen the trailer, here it is:

*Not to pile on ABC’s new shows. Dramas Nashville, Last Resort and Red Widow are all great, and 666 ain’t too shabby either.

TV Show
In Season
Complete Coverage

You May Like