Not unlike Catching Fire’s Finnick Odair, Lionsgate’s casting department is aiming carefully with its net. For the role of the endearingly arrogant tribute in the upcoming The Hunger Games sequel, they’re searching for a tall, good-looking, Caucasian male actor in his late 20s to early 30s.

I know what you’re thinking, because I thought the same thing at first: “How will they ever find someone in Hollywood who matches that description?” But according to a recent report, the studio has tracked down not just one but three actors who possess all those qualities: Garrett Hedlund, Armie Hammer, and Taylor Kitsch.The report also mentions that the role could still go to an unknown, but for now we’ll stick to speculating about these three. All of them fulfill the role’s first requirement: being good at not wearing a shirt. So the second — being able to play a character with a personality — may end up the deciding factor. Hedlund hasn’t been seen since he gave what critics called “a performance” in TRON: Legacy, but he’s got a few projects coming up, including On the Road in which he plays the charismatic Dean Moriarty. While the film received mixed reviews at Cannes, if Hedlund can hold his own as one of American literature’s indelible characters, then he might be a decent choice for this more delible character.

Armie Hammer (who will next star in The Lone Ranger opposite sidekick-slash-actual-star Johnny Depp) seems to me a tad too patrician for the role, and while Taylor Kitsch might be familiar with what it’s like to undergo a traumatic ordeal — if you think being forced into a televised battle to the death is bad, try starring in John Carter and Battleship back-to-back — I just don’t quite see him as a good fit.

What do you guys think? Do any of these names jump out at you as a good Finnick? (Yes, we know we asked you this same question only two months ago. We like our records to be up-to-date.)

Read more: