By Clark Collis
Updated May 23, 2012 at 04:24 PM EDT
Greg Peters/Everett Collection

Shortly before the release of 2010’s Will Forte-starring action-comedy MacGruber, the Saturday Night Live star told this writer that he would definitely like to make a sequel. “That is a dream scenario,” said the comic. “Just to be working with the same group of people would be awesome. I would love the chance to do that again… in a tropical setting.”

The chances of anyone ever putting up the dough for MacGruber 2 seemed subatomically slight after the film garnered some dismal reviews — EW’s Liza Schwarzbaum dismissed it as “90 minutes of talented performers doing and saying dumb, crude stuff in pursuit of an elusive laugh” — and a mere $4.1 million on its opening weekend. The good-natured Forte essentially admitted that he and director Jorma Taccone had laid a box-office egg last year when my colleague Grady Smith puckishly asked him, in the course of an “Awkward Questions” Q&A, what he had planned for MacGruber 3. The comedian’s reply? “We’re definitely gonna make Kristen Wiig’s part a little bigger and we’re gonna call it Bridesmaids 2: MacGruber 3. And the MacGruber 3 will be in very small print.”

So it comes as a surprise to learn that Forte and Taccone have been discussing a MacGruber sequel. Earlier this week the website Screen Crush quoted Taccone as saying that “Every time I hang out with Will, we talk about all our cool ideas for the sequel. We have the idea for it and we have a title, but I won’t tell you what it is.”

Truth be told, the idea of a MacGruber sequel is not quite as bizarre as it might at first appear. If the original film didn’t make money, it certainly didn’t lose that much thanks to its small $10 million budget. And Forte, Taccone, and co-writer John Solomon’s unhingedly risqué creation does have its fans. Devin Fraci of the Alamo Drafthouse blog Bada– Digest actually made MacGruber one of his top 10 movies of 2010, hailing Taccone’s directorial debut as “exactly the right combination of raunchy, stupid, anarchic and plain weird.” And just yesterday,‘s Tim Kelly wrote that “No comedy of the last few years is more deserving of a cult following than MacGruber.”

True, the film has yet to accrue the kind of cult fanbase which has developed around Tommy Wiseau’s so-bad-it’s-amazing The Room — a movie referenced in MacGruber — but that may be because it’s not that bad (for the record, this reporter supports any project in which Val Kilmer plays a character called “Dieter Von Cunth”).

The bad news for MacGruber fans is that Taccone looks likely to next make an adaptation of comic The Great Unknown (and the bad news for Forte’s hopes of filming somewhere tropical is that, according to Taccone, a sequel would follow in the footsteps of Die Hard by being Christmas-themed).

So here’s the question: Would you pay money to see MacGruber 2?

To help you decide, you can watch the trailer for the first film in what we’ve now decided to start calling “the MacGruber trilogy” below.

Read more: