By Jeff Labrecque
April 12, 2012 at 04:37 PM EDT
Gregg DeGuire/Getty Images
  • Movie

So The Avengers is one huge movie uniting six superheroes with amazing super origins and super skills. They partner up, somewhat reluctantly, when the Earth is threatened by Loki and his minions. But if push came to shove, as it does in a few scenes in the film, who would emerge supreme? Thor is a god, Iron Man is a flying weapon of mass destruction, and the Hulk is an angry green mutant. Would Black Widow and Hawkeye even have a chance? We asked the cast members at last night’s premiere in Hollywood which character would win a hypothetical battle royale in a steel cage, and they seemed to agree on the supe who would come out on top. (Hint: He’s green.)

Of greater interest, perhaps, was the general consensus on which actor would handle all comers. “I think in the end, Renner would probably win,” said Scarlett Johansson, echoing some of her other castmates. “Because he is a scrappy kind of guy. He’s done so many Bourne and Mission: Impossible type movies at this point that surely he’s picked up some special skills.”

Really? They said me?” said Renner. “I don’t know about that. Hemsworth and Evans have way more muscle than me. I’m not a fighter. I would rather shake some drinks and make martinis for everybody than fight them.”

Click through our photo gallery to see the stars on the red carpet and read their opinions on who’s the biggest, baddest of them all.

(Reporting by Carrie Bell.)

Read more:

‘The Avengers’ clip: Tony Stark confronts Loki, takes superhero head count

‘The Avengers’ clip: Cobie Smulders’ Maria Hill tussles with Nick Fury, verbally

‘The Avengers’: 21 New Photos

  • Movie
  • PG-13
Complete Coverage
Available For Streaming On