By Michelle Profis
March 29, 2012 at 05:42 PM EDT

We already brought you a first look of a horrified, cleavage-baring Jennifer Lawrence in the upcoming The House at the End of the Street, but now that the trailer for the upcoming horror flick has hit the Web, one thing is clear: Honey, we’re not in the arena anymore.

Taking a sharp dive from the badass, bow-and-arrow-wielding Katniss Everdeen, Lawrence next tackles the role of Elissa, a high schooler who moves to a house in a rural town with her mom, played by Elizabeth Shue. The catch? The town hosts an array of murderous secrets. Watch the trailer below:

The film hits on Sept. 21, but what are your thoughts on Lawrence’s new role?

Read more:

Jennifer Lawrence moves in beside ‘House at the End of the Street’ — FIRST LOOK

PopWatch Debate: Is Jennifer Lawrence too sexy to play Katniss?

20 Best Movie Makeovers