By Kate Ward
Updated February 08, 2012 at 09:05 PM EST

We feel your pain, Elena. It is extremely difficult to decide between the compassionate and handsome Stefan and the dark and dangerous (and handsome) Damon. But it’s even more difficult to decide which EW cover featuring the cast of The Vampire Diaries wins your heart. So while we gifted you with an issue on stands this week with three Vampire Diaries covers, we’re going to make you choose: Which cover image do you like best? (See the other two after the jump.) The one featuring Damon (Ian Somerhalder) and Elena (Nina Dobrev), the one featuring Stefan (Paul Wesley) and Elena (Nina Dobrev), or will you go with the best of both worlds and pick the one featuring Damon, Elena, and Stefan? Vote in our poll after the jump, and pick up the issue on stands Friday to devour ’em all. (Or click here to buy now!)

Read more:

This Week’s Cover: ‘Vampire Diaries’ love triangle

‘The Vampire Diaries’: Scoop from the set!

Photo Gallery: ‘Vampire Diaries’: 10 Exclusive Pics!