That’s what the readers of say. Better luck next year, Angelina. Maybe after you lose the baby bump, Beyoncé. Crediting her sense of humor as well as her down-to-earth, “unmistakably real” girl-next-door persona, the readers ranked her above Raquel Welch, Britney Spears, Marilyn Monroe, Angelina Jolie (put that in your pipe and smoke it, Brad!), and original Daisy Duke Catherine Bach, among others. Intriguingly, Aniston was only named #25 in the 2011 rankings. Guess getting a boyfriend and starring as a sex addict weren’t sexy enough to beat out Jennifer “Baywatch” Lawrence.

Aniston herself favors Brigitte Bardot and Gloria Steinem’s hotness to her own, but what do you think, PopWatchers? Do you agree with Men’s Health that Aniston is the hottest woman of all time? Or do you have eyes for another?