By Lanford Beard
Updated November 11, 2011 at 09:45 PM EST
Monty Brinton/CBS

Survivor just turned into Temptation Island. People revealed today that castaway Whitney Duncan, who began an on-air romance with fellow contestant Keith Tollefson, has been secretly married for more than a year. The former Nashville Star contestant married musician Donny Fallgatter in August 2010, though the newlyweds kept their marriage secret from friends and family. Duncan told Survivor: South Pacific producers she was single even while she made phone calls to her husband back in the U.S. Before filming wrapped, Duncan confessed over the phone that she’d started a romance with Tollefson. Now back Stateside, the showmancers have been spotted around Nashville, and it appears her relationship with Fallgatter is over — if only unofficially.

What do you make of this shocking revelation, PopWatchers? Does this news change your opinion of Duncan? Tollefson has already been voted off the island, but do you think Duncan has a chance of making it to the end?

Read more:

EW Recaps: Survivor

‘Survivor: South Pacific’: New cast and new twists revealed!

‘Footloose’: What country superstar is covering the title song for the upcoming remake? We reveal the soundtrack listing! — EXCLUSIVE