By Jeff Labrecque
Updated May 20, 2011 at 01:11 PM EDT

One night after slipping on stage, Haley Reinhart was eliminated on American Idol, leaving only two teenage contestants remaining. But she did not go down like a lead balloon (oof), planting the seeds of voter regret with a sassy, relaxed rendition of Elton John’s “Bennie and the Jets.” The girl’s got a future.

Watch her finale performance embedded after the jump. Do you think her stumble cinched her elimination? And do you think America will regret sending her home?

For more contestant videos, photos, and Idol news, check out

Read more: