By Andy Greenwald
May 04, 2011 at 04:00 AM EDT
F. Scott Schafer

Turtleneck & Chain


Truly, ”D— in a Box” is the gift that keeps on giving for the Lonely Island, the nom de fake rap of Saturday Night Live star Andy Samberg and his BFFs, SNL writer-directors Jorma Taccone and Akiva Schaffer. Since that brilliant, indisputably instructive R&B satire first appeared in 2006, the trio — along with featured players like Rihanna, T-Pain, and a very game Justin Timberlake — has had remarkable success in the notoriously difficult genre of ”funny music,” hitting a neat balance of parody and sweet-natured homage (peppered with plenty of references to their respective junk). Now, two years after Incredibad, a debut that collected many of the group’s greatest, previously televised hits, comes Turtleneck & Chain, a perfectly acceptibad follow-up. On ”Motherlover,” honorary Islander Timberlake returns for a deeply filthy, proudly MILF-y ode to ”pushing that way where you came out as a baby,” while the triumphantly goofy ”I Just Had Sex,” with Akon, manages to be both outrageous and entirely plausible radio bait. Rihanna, Nicki Minaj, a sleepy, maybe-not-in-on-the-joke Snoop Dogg, and ”major cinephile” Michael Bolton(!) all make appearances — but it’s the chameleonic core trio that truly surprises. At one point, over a classic, adrenalized hip-hop beat, Samberg and Taccone trade fierce criminology rhymes with a swagger that’s downright serious. Until, of course, one notices the title: ”Trouble on Dookie Island.”

Download These:
We’re Back!, a ferocious intro, at
Attracted to Us, a nerd-pop call-and-response, at

See all of this week’s reviews

Turtleneck & Chain

  • Music
Complete Coverage
  • Turtleneck & Chain