James Durbin Sheryl Crow American Idol

Update: Annie’s recap is live.

Now that we’ve debated which songs the Top 5 should sing from Now & Then Night, it’s time to watch our young contenders fling themselves at the feet of the three Fates… and then gossip about ‘em!

Chat here about American Idol‘s performance show, then come back later for my full recap and a detailed on-the-scene report. THIS! Is Entertainment Weekly.

Read more: ‘American Idol’

Is Jimmy Iovine the new Simon? (He wishes!)

All of EW.com’s ‘Idol’ episode recaps

Exclusive on-the-scene ‘Idol’ reports

Annie on Twitter