By Annie Barrett
Updated April 12, 2011 at 05:19 PM EDT

I didn’t think it would ever come to this. The two loves of my life — now bonded by the same classical tune — must face off in a devastating Lunchtime Poll. On last night’s Dancing With the Stars, Kirstie Alley and my imaginary boyfriend Maksim Chmerkovskiy danced a (nearly shoeless) waltz to “The Flower Duet,” a.k.a. the glorious song from the Ghirardelli chocolate commercial, as if to remind us that Maks’ booty is the “most intense, slow-melting, premium chocolate” of all Pro booty. I suddenly wondered: If forced to choose between having a) one dance with my imaginary boyfriend Maks, or b) the reliable pleasure of my real boyfriend, a giant Ghirardelli chocolate bar, what would I do? What would you do? Help me decide, below.

I sure threw a wrench in there with that last one!

Here’s Maks and Kirstie’s performance video, for reference.

Chmerkovskiy. A timeless pleasure.

Read more:

‘DWTS’ recap: The Taming of the Shoe’s ‘Dancing With the Stars’ Central

All Food and Drink posts on PopWatch

All Lunchtime Polls on PopWatch

Follow Annie on Twitter