By Annie Barrett
April 07, 2011 at 12:00 PM EDT

Update: Annie’s recap is live

Wednesday’s Rock and Roll Hall of Fame Night sure was fun. Everyone did fairly well. No disasters. No more dizzies! But someone’s gotta go home. Earlier today, we suggested Stefano, Jacob, and Paul would be heading to the stools of doom around 8:50 tonight. You voted — most of you picked Stefano or Jacob. My gut is telling me “Stefano,” but my gut is saying “time to eat frozen pizza and raw cookie dough” and I’m just not sure it’s a good idea to listen. Chat about the results show here, and I’ll update this post as soon as we know which of the top 9 has been eliminated. Update: Pia Toscano was eliminated. What?!?!?! She’s been considered a frontrunner pretty much the whole time. “I have no idea what just happened here,” said J. Lo.

Stefano Langone and Jacob Lusk joined Pia in the bottom three.

Look for my full recap later tonight. Update: here it is.

Read more on ‘American Idol’:

Who will go home tonight? Vote!

‘American Idol’ recap: The Rock Garden

How much does what a contestant says affect your vote?

‘Idol’ coaches talk the Top 9 — EXCLUSIVE

On the scene for Top 9 performance night

Follow Annie on Twitter