Image Credit: Sylvain Gaboury/PR Photos; Donna Ward/PR PhotosAs the movie adaptation of Pride and Prejudice and Zombies chews its way through potential directors like undead jaws through brains, the various parts of Abraham Lincoln: Vampire Hunter, based on a book by PPZ author Seth Grahame-Smith, are slowly coming into place. Wanted director Timur Bekmambetov has settled comfortably in the director’s chair, and he has already chosen a lead: Benjamin Walker, who is best-known for playing Andrew Jackson in the Broadway musical Bloody Bloody Andrew Jackson and who, from the looks of it, is trying to act his way through the ranks of American paper currency.

Additionally, The Hurt Locker’s Anthony Mackie is in talks to join the Tim Burton-produced feature as Will, Lincoln’s best friend, while Dominic Cooper (Mamma Mia!, Tamara Drewe) will likely play Honest Abe’s mentor, Henry, who, in the source material, is also the individual that reveals Lincoln’s true, vampire-staking story to the book’s narrator. There are some rumors floating around that actress Robin McLeavy will be playing Lincoln’s wife, Mary Todd, but a source tells EW that she is only one of three actresses currently vying for the role.

There are still plenty of characters to be cast: From Alaska-purchaser and fellow hunter William Seward to vampiric assassin John Wilkes Booth. In the book, Lincoln even runs into Edgar Allan Poe — poet, writer, and Christopher Nolan precursor — who, of course, knows all about the vampires. John Cusack is already taking on the role of Poe in the upcoming The Raven, so my suggestion for AL:VH is Jeffrey Combs, who was terribly creepy in The Frighteners, among many other horror flicks, and has already played Poe to great effect in an episode of Masters of Horror. Or maybe even Joaquin Phoenix, who was reportedly in talks to play Henry and had also been rumored to play Poe in a totally different project nearly a year ago. Plus, he’s got that dark look about him, and I’m pretty sure he has no issue pulling off “eccentric.”

Read more: