By EW Staff
February 13, 2011 at 12:00 PM EST

As predicted by absolutely nobody, excellent Montreal indie band Arcade Fire beat favorites Eminem and Lady Antebellum for the night’s top award, the Album of the Year Grammy. First thing out of frontman Win Butler’s mouth at the podium: “What the hell?” We couldn’t agree more, but it’s the best kind of surprise, as was their bonus performance of “Ready To Start” right after their acceptance speech (which was weird; is there any way they didn’t know they were going to win given that setup?). Combine this with Esperanza Spalding’s bizarro win in the Best New Artist category and this was an amazing year for underdogs.

What do you think of Arcade Fire’s big win? Did anyone see this coming, or is it totally out of nowhere?

More on the Grammys from

2011 Grammy Awards: We’re live-blogging it!

Bieber and Usher relive their history for Grammy performance

Lady Gaga’s Grammys arrival is predictably weird: See it here

Lady Gaga Performs “Born This Way” at the Grammys

Grammys 2011: The winners list