The first week of American Idol‘s season nine finals is in the books, and conventional wisdom would have us believe it’s already down to a battle between dark and unpredictable Siobhan Magnus and serious, steady Crystal Bowersox. But in the world of Idol, sometimes a fabulous early front-runner is a shock elimination waiting to happen. (Just ask Chris Daughtry!)

On this week’s Idolatry,‘s Dawnie Walton and I sit down to discuss which of this season’s midpack players has a chance to shake up the Crystal-Siobhan party, and I get an early top-three vision. Plus, we discuss the hot, buttered wrecks of Rolling Stones week. Fun! Press play below, and then share your thoughts in the comments. If you’re having trouble with the video, you can watch this week’s episode (and past seasons) at our Idolatry hub. And don’t forget to follow me on Twitter @EWMichaelSlezak.