By Annie Barrett
Updated January 25, 2010 at 06:04 PM EST
Credit: Utah County Jail

What do we think: Scariest mug shot of all time or super-scariest mugshot of all time? He looks like a cross between Yoda, an evildoer in Leprechaun, and this adorable little kid we used to know named Arnold. Coleman may want to start having his Avenue Q stand-ins during upcoming appearances in mug shots. Those ladies might need work, too.

After being brought to jail for a domestic disturbance at his home in Santaquin, Utah, Coleman, 41, was arrested on an outstanding warrant for failing to appear in court. Maybe he and wife Shannon Price should go on Divorce Court again? Would that cheer him up?

Image credit: Utah County Jail