By Wendy Mitchell
December 15, 2009 at 06:00 PM EST

We’re in the Semifinals of our Guilty Pleasures Reality TV Showdown (see full bracket here). Now we’re into the Celeb-Reality category.

Semifinals, Celeb-Reality: The Surreal Life vs. Keeping up with the Kardashians

Here’s what some fans had to say during the first round of voting:

Ailene on Keeping up with the Kardashians: “Yes, they have no real reason to be on tv, but they’re entertaining.”

Remy on The Surreal Life: “It led to VH1’s entire line-up for most of the decade – it spawned Celeb-reality. Especially in the earlier seasons, the show was just plain addicting to watch the drama unfold.”

Relive some classic moments on video — and vote — after the jump.

The Surreal Life (warning: shows Verne Troyer in a state of undress)

Keeping Up with the Kardashians

More on

Guilty Pleasures Reality TV Showdown Kickoff!

Updated bracket

Other Semifinal matchups — polls still open!

Semifinals, Relationships: Flavor of Love vs. Temptation Island

Semifinals, Relationships: Cheaters vs. Rock of Love

Semifinals, “Real” Lives: The Real Housewives of New Jersey vs. Say Yes to the Dress

Semifinals, “Real” Lives: My Super Sweet 16 vs. Dog the Bounty Hunter

Semifinals, Celeb-Reality: Newlyweds: Nick and Jessica vs. The Anna Nicole Show