We’re in the Semifinals of our Guilty Pleasures Reality TV Showdown (see full bracket here).

Semifinals, “Real” Lives: My Super Sweet 16 vs. Dog the Bounty Hunter

Here’s what some fans had to say during the first round of voting:

“et” on My Super Sweet 16: “I don’t think I’m exaggerating when I say My Super Sweet Sixteen is proof of the end of Western civilization. (That’s not to say I haven’t seen the entirety of most of the early seasons.)”

Cowboy Roy on Dog the Bounty Hunter: “It should be a crime to be able to kick so much ass. And the Dogisms … don’t even get me started!”

Relive some classic moments on video — and vote — after the jump.

My Super Sweet 16

Dog the Bounty Hunter

Tell us in the comments below why you love the show you voted for.

Vote in more EW Guilty Reality-TV Pleasures semifinal matchups: