By Mandi Bierly
December 11, 2009 at 09:56 PM EST

I’ll be honest: I never saw 2001’s Cats & Dogs even though I have a stuffed Mr. Tinkles from the film in my office. (I made that the nickname for my former cube mate, so now I’m stuck with it for sentimental reasons.) That said, I’m kinda into the sequel, which, in addition to cats and dogs working together to stop the evil (and naturally hairless) Kitty Galore, features 30 Rock‘s Jack McBrayer (!), former Grey’s Anatomy veterinarian Chris O’Donnell, and SNL‘s Fred Armisen in the flesh. Suck it, G-Force.*

Who else hates to admit they’d totally watch this?

* Though I kinda wanted to see that, too.