By Ken Tucker
September 18, 2009 at 03:37 PM EDT

I’m wrapping up this week of Will Win/Should Win predictions for the Emmys by jumping to the Reality Competition Program category.

The nominees are: The Amazing Race, American Idol, Dancing With The Stars, Project Runway, and Top Chef.

The Amazing Race has always won in this category, and I like Race a lot. But I think this is the year Top Chef will defeat it. Chef is classy enough for Emmy voters who think it’s time to spread the wealth a bit and may find Idol and Dancing a tad too cheesy for their tastes.

See? Taste! Top Chef has the advantage.

So please tell me: Who do you think will win?