By Whitney Pastorek
Updated July 29, 2009 at 04:00 AM EDT

Despite this Nashville foursome’s attempts to garner comparisons to ?Fleetwood Mac — the first track here all but breaks out into the chorus of ”Rhiannon” — the vast majority of their debut album, Gloriana, falls somewhere between maudlin boy-band songwriting clichés and? a particularly melodramatic Six Flags country revue. But the simpler tunes someone sneaked onto the end (”Come and Save Me,” ”Time to Let Me Go”) show promise. Lose the tinny, cheesy overproduction and half of the hair product, and these kids might have something. C

Download This: Listen to the song Come and Save Me on the band’s MySpace

See all of this week’s reviews