By Chris Nashawaty
April 08, 2009 at 04:00 AM EDT

Aiming for The Dark Knight but landing closer to Adam West, Frank Miller’s Sin City follow-up, The Spirit, is a flashy dud. ?Macht has zero charisma as the masked hero and ?Jackson has too much as the villain. Scarlett ?Johansson and Eva Mendes, playing a pair of femmes fatales, just look lost. Among the EXTRAS is a self-pleased commentary from Miller and his producer. What movie were they watching? C

See all current DVD reviews from EW