By Mike Bruno
January 23, 2009 at 06:21 PM EST

American Idol fans are upset that season 8 contender Joanna Pacitti reportedly already has an album and a Broadway show on her resume, MSNBC reports. Pacitti, who was sent through to Hollywood on Wednesday night’s episode of Idol, was cast in a Broadway production of Annie at age 11 and released the 2006 album This Crazy Life on Geffen. She also appeared on the soundtrack for Legally Blonde, sang “Out From Under” from the Bratz movie, and was featured in one of MTV’s True Life episodes. Several former Idol contenders have caused controversy due to their past experience in the business, including last season’s Kristy Lee Cookand Carly Smithson, but some fans feel that Pacitti’s experience is too deep for her to compete on the show.