By Tina Jordan
Updated January 14, 2009 at 05:00 AM EST

The Story: When Ivy ?and David clear out the junk accumulated over the ?years in their sprawling ?Victorian house, one woman who comes to the tag sale goes missing — ?and police soon finger David for her disappearance and murder in Never Tell a Lie.
Exotic Locale: Brush Hills, Mass.
Movie Pitch: An updated Fatal ?Attraction.
Lowdown: Though Hallie Ephron’s basic idea? is a good one, she’s delivered a clunky, plodding mystery, and an even worse psychological thriller. This one’s a miss. D