By Mandi Bierly
October 07, 2008 at 03:15 PM EDT

Maybe you wouldn’t go back to high school, but I’m guessing some movie or TV show has made you wish you were 18 again, if only for a second. So which one is it, and why?

The thought definitely crossed my mind during Nick & Norah’s Infinite Playlist (pictured), thanks to the always-charming Michael Cera, and the fact that Nick’s gay pals would have loved me.

I wonder if, given the opportunity when I was that age, I would’ve crushed on Cera instead of Keanu Reeves (Speed) and Brad Pitt (Legends of the Fall)…

Your turn.

More on Michael Cera:

Inappropriate Crush Quiz No. 2: Michael Cera edition
Video: Michael Cera and Jason Bateman talk Juno
Video: Michael Cera and Jonah Hill talk Superbad
Interview: EW’s Superbad roundtable