It was like a scene straight out of Gossip Girl: Tensions flare between two BFFs after one of them is caught rolling her eyes at the other during a live television interview. The situation escalates when the clip makes its way onto the Internet and quickly becomes a viral sensation, igniting talk that the divas are now dueling.

Unfortunately for Sisterhood of the Traveling Pants costars Blake Lively and America Ferrera, this was no juicy soap plot; it was real life. And now, in this exclusive video interview conducted over the weekend at Gossip Girl‘s season 2 premiere party, Lively for the first time reacts to the hullabaloo, and clears the air about what really transpired behind the scenes at the now-infamous satellite interview.

Well, don’t just sit there rolling your eyes — push play!