As I watched Sugarland’s latest video, “All I Want To Do” (below), followed by Jessica Simpson’s country debut, “Come On Over” (even lower), I realized that they are prime examples of “Good Sexy” vs. “Bad Sexy.”

In the Sugarland cut, Jennifer Nettles’ sex appeal is rooted in the fact that she’s having a blast in that bikini. And that she’s the best dancer country music has ever seen (sorry, LeAnn). I’ve got a total girl crush on her.

Jessica Simpson, on the other hand, looks like she’s trying too hard — again. Those well-lit shots of her in the bed of a pickup truck could be straight out of a Playboy video. I’d love to see her try to sell her vocals and not her legs. But, then again, I’m not a man.

Which video do you find sexier? And how do you define “good sexy” vs. “bad sexy?” Tell it!