The folks behind ''American Pie 2'' bake up a new batch of humiliations for the randy youngsters

By Rebecca Ascher-Walsh
August 17, 2001 at 04:00 AM EDT
  • Movie

WARNING: This article contains graphic language including but not limited to the words ”tantric,” ”ovaries,” and ”pie.”

Even for a group of kids willing to get funky with a pie, find erotic uses for a flute, and strip on the Internet, there are limits. Namely, doing it all again.

As the 1999 comedy ”American Pie” boinked its way to more than $100 million at the box office, Universal Pictures started salivating for a sequel. But the stars didn’t necessarily want to go back for seconds. ”Sequels give me the willies,” says Jason Biggs, who stars as the hapless Jim. ”We all had reservations.” Not that it mattered: Pie’s lead actors — including Chris Klein (Oz) and Seann William Scott (Stifler) — were under contract. As Eddie Kaye Thomas, who plays the brainy eccentric Finch, puts it, ”They could’ve wiped their a–es on a piece of toilet paper and I would have had to film it.”

Luckily for them, equally anxious Adam Herz, the first movie’s screenwriter, agreed to write the sequel (on 8 1/2” x 11” 20-pound stock, we’re relieved to report). Which means that this week, audiences will be treated to the further misadventures of the potty-mouthed, undersexed, always embarrassed teens in ”American Pie 2,” directed by J.B. Rogers (first assistant director on the original). The guys, along with returning female foils Alyson Hannigan (as band-camp devotee Michelle), Tara Reid, Natasha Lyonne, Shannon Elizabeth, and Mena Suvari, are brought back together in a plot that finds them the summer after their freshman year in college. And while the pals may be older, they aren’t necessarily any wiser — at least not when confronting lesbians, the intricacies of tantric sex, and bras that refuse to unsnap.

EW What’s up with the movie’s ”Rule of Three,” which states that men multiply their number of sex partners by three, and women divide by three?

BIGGS I think it’s accurate.

KLEIN It’s definitely got a jingle.

ROGERS If a girl has sex with a couple of guys, she’s a slut, and a guy’s a stud. We wanted to attack the double standard.

HERZ Three is probably too much, but two is definitely not enough. We weren’t going to call it the Rule of 2.2.

EW Any other pearls of wisdom gleaned about the opposite sex during the shoot?

THOMAS Men aren’t the only ones who want to have sex.

BIGGS It became quite clear that women have the upper hand.

HANNIGAN The boys on the movie are wonderful, but…I learned I like older men.

KLEIN I’ve still got a lot of questions.

EW How’d the scene in which Stifler and Jim make out in front of two lesbians go?

ROGERS They both hated it. I was like, ”You have to kiss longer or I can’t do the cutaway shots.” They’d say, ”Oh, okay, one more time.” I’d say, ”No, 17 more times.”

SCOTT I’ve kissed Ashton Kutcher [in ”Dude, Where’s My Car?”], which was kind of dreadful. Jason’s a good kisser.

BIGGS I heard that Seann said Ashton was a better kisser. But we’ll work through it. We’ll be kissing again in no time.

  • Movie
  • R
  • 104 minutes
Complete Coverage