Each actor took turns standing blindfolded in a ring surrounded by four rotating piñatas, tasked with kicking as many as possible with 20 seconds on the clock.
It sounded like fun when Fallon explained the rules to Mackie, but then he introduced Macchio. “No! Come on!” he exclaimed.
Even with all his Avengers: Infinity War-level glutes, Mackie was able to kick down two piñatas. It wasn’t enough to combat Macchio’s skills. The Cobra Kai star struck his iconic one-legged pose and executed his final game-winning blow.
Watch the game play out above.