Would Kate Upton, Sports Illustrated‘s Swimsuit cover model, learn to fall in love with Jimmy Kimmel if both stars were stranded on an island? Upton had to ponder that and two other of the late-night host’s “Ridiculous Questions” on Jimmy Kimmel Live Thursday.
“The longer you think about it the more insulting it actually becomes,” Kimmel said, dressed as a bartender while serving Upton a Morgan Mule cocktail.
“I guess so,” she resolved.
“That’s the most beautiful thing anyone’s ever said to me,” Kimmel joked.
The host also asked Upton about why people are scared of clowns (not such a “Ridiculous Question”), and if she’d rather have pies for feet or wooden teeth. “Probably because so many clowns kill people,” she laughed at first, before reasoning that she could eat her feet if they were pies.
Watch the bit in the video above.