Entertainment Weekly


Stay Connected


Advertise With Us

Learn More

Skip to content
Emmys 2017
Every unforgettable moment, every gorgeous dress.Click here


The X Factor recap: Chicago, Seattle auditions

Auditions continue in Chicago and Seattle; Simon accuses Paula and Nicole of hating the ladies

Posted on

X Factor Drew Ryniewicz

The X Factor

TV Show
Current Status:
Reality TV

Vroom vroom! Stevecrest Jones continued his whirlwind three-truck tour of the U.S. as The X Factor held auditions in Chicago and Seattle. What’s in the trucks, Steve?

The Chicago auditions definitely looked much better than what we saw in premiere week. Maybe it was the vastness of the auditorium, or the bright purpleness of the giant X. (Purple’s so much friendlier and hopeful than red. Justin Bieber, on the other hand, likes both purple and red.) Maybe it was the presence of Cheryl Cole, who returned for an unexpected one-hour-only U.S. X Factor tribute tour. Maybe it was just my mood! Anyway, Chicago and Seattle were overall much more compelling than last Thursday’s ridiculous snoozefest. Let’s run down the yeses:

Brock and Makenna, 18 and 22, from Springfield, Missouri. I loved their hugging moms! The Chicago camera crew kept focusing on the same five girls in the audience, which I actually enjoyed — it made the production much less disjointed, meaning I no longer felt like the cameras had been affixed to dusty beach balls. These girls were VERY sad when Makenna announced she and floppy yellow-haired Brock were not dating. I’m not sad about it. She seems controlling. The pair harmonized beautifully on “Colder Weather,” prompting L.A. Reid to groove so hard that his scarf (!) nearly swallowed his head. “I think your vocal blend is very lovely,” said Paula Abdul, sole proprietor of Planet Paula, saving herself from what I thought was a much sharper previous comment: “It’s a rarity to have two people come onstage and come together and nail.” Patience, Paula.

My love affair with L.A. Reid continued as he shot down a clown-like woman named Robin Royal with a matter-of-fact “Not for me. Not right now.” It’s like he’s at a restaurant! Mmm, restaurants.

Skyelor Anderson, 16, from rural Mississippi, does not visit many restaurants. “We go to bonfires and fish a lot,” he explained. I love everything about him — his genuine love for country music, the way he followed his instinct to just keep singing after his track suddenly cut out, his motorcycle factory worker mom and her bad teeth, the whimsical spelling of “Skyelor.” Everything! Well, okay, his voice I could give or take. Paula did say he needed to work on that. But Cheryl’s priorities were in the right place: “You look great.”

NEXT: ‘It sounded so bad, but felt so good.’ Four yeses!