Entertainment Weekly


Stay Connected


Advertise With Us

Learn More

Skip to content
Emmys 2017
Every unforgettable moment, every gorgeous dress.Click here


Justin wins, but was Angela robbed?

Justin wins, but was Angela robbed? A Backstreet Boy look-alike and a Texan singing Aretha join Justin in the finals, but Jessica Shaw doubts either has a chance of winning it all

Posted on

Justin Guarini, American Idol

American Idol

TV Show
Current Status:
In Season
Harry Connick Jr., Jennifer Lopez, Keith Urban, Ryan Seacrest
Reality TV

Justin wins, but was Angela robbed?

This week had the lusciously perfect Justin doing Stevie Wonder justice (unlike that pumpkinhead Gil), but beyond that, I didn’t find the second round of contestants all that interesting. Last week there was drama, tension, potential romance, and Kelli’s hair. This week?

Sure, the underage Alexis had it going on, and Tenia’s dress was worth a guffaw or two, but are we really going to remember Jazmin or Kelly after tonight? Oh, wait. Kelly actually made the cut. How is it possible that the utterly forgetable (even Simon admitted he couldn’t remember her) ”R-E-S-P-E-C-T” singer got a spot in the finals before Angela, whose rendition of ”Run to You” would have made Whitney proud? Still, Justin must have been relieved since she is no competition for him.

Of course, neither is A.J., who somehow managed to draw criticism from the annoyingly nice Paula Abdul. The guy looks like ‘N Sync, has a Backstreet Boy name, and sings O-Town? Hello, no career beyond 25!

Still, like Jim ”Moonlight Kisses” Verraros before him, A.J. scored with the sympathy vote. Simon dissed him big time and America felt the need to defend our own (especially ’cause he sang the ”Star Spangled Banner” in his first audition) against the Brit. ”I think there were better people on the show,” Simon said to the clearly shocked winner tonight. Yeah, no duh.

Try pretty much everyone except Jamar (that’s right, one name), whose version of ”Careless Whisper” may yet send George Michael back to random men’s bathrooms, and Alexandra, who would barely get an honorable mention at a high school talent show.

On to more disturbing thoughts. I’m not sure which made me come closer to pukage: the ridiculous Ford product placement (at least Ryan and Brian weren’t offering everyone Cokes this week), when Gil asked Paula out on a date, or when Paula said yes. Will Gil and Paula be on the cover of next week’s Star? Has-been reality show hostess found canoodling with reject! What’s up with all the contestants thinking Paula is such a hottie? Am I crazy or does she scream washed-up Laker Girl?

The most interesting part of the show may end up being who gets the judges’ wild card vote. Last week I would have said that Chris had that spot locked up, but after this week’s surprises, Alexis or Angela may find themselves competing for the record contract. By the way, I have a newfound respect for Alexis, who lost with dignity and charm…which is more than I can say about that hideous Kelli. That’s right, people. Any opportunity I can get to take Kelli down one notch further, I’m there. Got a problem with that?