It’s always a special occasion when two late-night hosts appear on the same show. So when Watch What Happens: Live‘s Andy Cohen stopped by The Tonight Show on Monday night, host Jimmy Fallon greeted him with the debut of a new game: Muff of Truth. The game involved both hosts putting their hands into the same pink muff, and then saying something they’d never admitted in public before. There was even a little Seussian incantation to kick things off, read by Fallon: “Here we stand, with hands in muff, the time has come, enough’s enough.”
Fallon then made his confession: For the past two years, he’s watched Gilmore Girls every night before going to bed in preparation for the upcoming Netflix revival. Fallon then passed the torch to Cohen, who read, “The muff is warm, our hands are sweaty, thy truth be told, for I am ready.” Cohen then admitted he once mistakenly sexted his sister. “The Muff of Truth!” Fallon declared, as they pulled away.
Watch the clip below.