Allison Sadlier
August 03, 2016 AT 02:51 PM EDT

Remember that pizza man who delivered a delicious dish of Frank Sinatra on America’s Got Talent and earned Heidi Klum’s golden buzzer earlier this summer? Well, Sal Valentinetti was back to compete Tuesday night, and he brought more than just a few flashy toppings.

Dressed in a white dinner jacket and bow tie, the 20-year-old Long Island, New York, native sang a jazzy rendition of One Direction’s “Story of My Life” with Sinatra’s style and a full jazz band behind him. His multi-platform stage even sparkled with “SAL” at the end.

“Hey Simon, you can pay me later for this one pal,” Sal joked to Simon Cowell (who helped form One Direction) before holding his final note in the grand finale.

The audience and judges gave Valentinetti a standing ovation for his show-stoppping performance and he thanked the crowd in true showman fashion, saying, “I love yas all!”

Watch the full video below.

You May Like