Jimmy Fallon brought Box of Lies back on Tuesday night for Lena Dunham’s appearance on The Tonight Show. The night before, he had invented a new game of Slip N’ Flip with Liam Hemsworth; Box of Lies, by contrast, is now a storied part of Fallon’s tenure, and Tuesday’s edition reminded viewers why. It’s just so weird.
Dunham went first and opened a box full of pictures of Leonardo DiCaprio labeled “Frances McDormand.” It was so random that Dunham didn’t really know what to do; she decided to try out-weirding it by telling Fallon she actually got a banana dressed up with Sideshow Bob hair and googly eyes, but her over-enthusiasm helped Fallon see right through her.
Next was Fallon’s turn, and he got a cauldron full of rubber ducks. He tried passing it off as a Barbie Hot Tub. It took little time for Dunham to debunk that. “As if you could recognize a Barbie Hot Tub,” Dunham said.
“I probably could, I have two little girls!” Fallon said.
Dunham’s second box, the final tiebreaker round, was so weird it put the others to shame: a book of Grimm’s Fairy Tales with the interior pages carved out, The Shawshank Redemption style, to hold a bottle of whiskey. For this last round, Dunham finally changed her strategy. She told the truth, and fooled Fallon. Truth is ever stranger than fiction.
Watch the clip below.