Before Mindy Lahiri found her Mr. Right in Danny Castellano, it seemed like her luck with love would never come to fruition. She’s struck out with her share of cheating jerks (Dennis, Josh), lawyers (Josh, Cliff), doctors (Jeremy, Brendan, Tom), and even a male prostitute (Adam). Though there was a slight glimmer of hope when she packed up her life to live in Haiti with her DJ’ing pastor fiancé, Casey, it was the person in front of her the whole time with whom she fell in love.
As we last saw Danny trekking to India to profess his undying love to an expectant Mindy’s parents, the future for one of TV’s favorite couples remains unknown. Season 4 of The Mindy Project kicks off Tuesday (on its new home on Hulu) with a Sliding Doors-inspired look at what Mindy’s life would be like if she never got involved with Danny. In honor of the premiere, let’s take a trip down memory lane to see which of her former flames could’ve made the cut.
WANT MORE EW? Subscribe now to keep up with the latest in movies, television, music, and more.