Entertainment Weekly


Stay Connected


Advertise With Us

Learn More

Skip to content
Join our live viewing party of the 'This Is Us' season premiere.

This is Us

Tonight at 9PM ET


'Mr. Robinson': EW review

Posted on

Vivian Zink/NBC

Mr. Robinson

TV Show
Current Status:
In Season
run date:
Craig Robinson

We gave it a C-

Mr. Robinson greets you with a bawdy bear hug of good-natured naughty comedy courtesy of its effortlessly funny star, Hot Tub Time Machine’s Craig Robinson. We find him playing keyboards and crooning a double-entendre-laced ditty called “Chocolate Muffins” with his band, the Nasty Delicious. “I will mix your batter with my wooden spoon,” he sings. “When I say ‘preheat,’ you say ‘oven’/Preheat!/Oven!” Everyone plays along and laughs; so do we.

If Mr. Robinson were only moments like this, it might really cook. This six-episode set belongs to that tradition of TV laugher that tries to turn a comedian’s life (Robinson really does have a band called the Nasty Delicious) into a star vehicle with a sitcomish storytelling engine. At best, you get something inventive and transcendent like Seinfeld; at worst, you get something watery and forgettable like…um…oh, yeah! Mulaney. Mr. Robinson aspires to something like Welcome Back, Kotter—he takes a job teaching music at his old high school to earn cash and score with a fellow alum-turned-teacher (Meagan Good)—but the series lands somewhere close to…um…what was that show again?

Robinson, for his part, is loose and sharp and wise to the needs of a scene. He gives great banter, and his friendly persona warms everything stale about the storytelling. Yet “warms” isn’t the same as “freshens.” You’ve seen these stories before. The one about auditioning for a record exec. The one about saving the music program. The one where someone babysits a dog and it runs away. The few worthwhile themes are subverted by absurd, borderline-racist characterizations and ribald pop-culture-referencing dialogue that tries way too hard. Here’s to you, Mr. Robinson: You deserve better. C–