Maybe one day Jimmy Fallon will finally run out of entertaining, meme-ready variations on classic games, but not any time soon. Tuesday night, it was Jennifer Garner’s turn in the celebrity hot seat, as she faced The Tonight Show host in a modified game of Rock-Paper-Scissors.
This take was much more cartoon-y than The Big Bang Theory‘s nerdy variation, however. Instead of adding Lizard and Spock, her game with Fallon added pie as a unique, chaotic element. The two players stand behind cartoon cut-outs and play, but whoever loses each round has to fire a mechanism in front of them, Russian roulette style, that may or may not pie them in the face.
Garner gets pied, and the whole thing is a charming reminder of what made Fallon EW‘s Entertainer of the Year last year.