It’s that time again. From Sleepy Hollow‘s eye-magnet Tom Mison to NBC’s “Thursday pit of sitcom despair,” EW has unveiled our list of fall TV winners and losers. The list has some controversial choices this year. Can we really call TV’s top-rated new fall series a loser and the star of one of the lowest-rated new comedies a winner? See if you agree with our logic. Check out the gallery here.