Entertainment Weekly


Stay Connected


Advertise With Us

Learn More

Skip to content
Join our live viewing party of the 'This Is Us' season premiere.

This is Us

Tonight at 9PM ET


Season 5: How Barney Dated Robin

We go over what happened in the show’s fifth season and name the season’s best episode

Posted on

Season 5 kicks off with Barney trying something totally different: a relationship with Robin. Alas, the happily-ever-after is not meant to be…yet. After the breakup, Barney jumps right back into the dating scene, but a hurt Robin takes time before falling for Don (Benjamin Koldyke), her once-reviled coanchor. They end things when he takes a job in Chicago…that she first turned down. But this season isn’t all relationship drama: Marshall finds time to dole out the fourth slap of the slap bet on Thanksgiving, a.k.a. ”Slapsgiving 2: Revenge of the Slap,” while Ted becomes an architecture professor and buys a fixer-upper where his family will eventually live. With no long-term girlfriend this season, he goes on an ill-fated date with Cindy (Rachel Bilson), who we learn is actually The Mother’s roommate (and a future lesbian). Throughout, Lily and Marshall struggle with whether they are ready to start a family. The season wraps with Lily asking Marshall to ”put a baby in my belly.”

Best Episode: ”Girls vs. Suits” Ted realizes it’s not Cindy but her roommate who’s perfect for him, and viewers get the most revealing glimpse of The Mother — her foot! — to date. MacLaren’s hires a hot bartender (Stacy Keibler) who doesn’t go for guys in suits. Barney tries to don T-shirts, but by episode’s end he’s got the whole cast singing an all-out love song to, what else, suits.

Best Sound Bite ”You just gotta make [grading papers] fun. For example, every time I spot a grammatical error, I do a shot. I’m trashed right now, and I blame our public-school system.” —Ted