Kellie Pickler and Derek Hough
Week 6, quickstep
After a busy week of (jokingly) rooting for each other to fail during rehearsals, the couple earned their first 10s with a flash-footed Stevie Wonder tribute featuring unbeweavable hair and a sparkly cleavage snake.
Alexandra Raisman and Mark Ballas
Week 4, contemporary
The interpretive routine about Aly’s gymnastics career (ain’t it funny how contemporary equals tumbling passes on a ballroom-dancing show?) demonstrated a perfect balance of emotion and athleticism.
Zendaya and Val Chmerkovskiy
Week 5, Argentine tango
The Disney kid had no trouble keeping up with Val and returning pros Anna Trebunskaya and Maksim Chmerkovskiy. ”Sharp and tangy at the top, crisp and tasty down below,” proclaimed Len Goodman.
Jacoby Jones and Karina Smirnoff
Week 5, jive
The NFL star’s bionic knees propelled this high-energy number, which proved suspenders over a bare chest is sexier than DWTS‘ typical shirtless look. ”Testosterone pouring from everywhere!” cried Bruno Tonioli.
Andy Dick and Sharna Burgess
Week 4, Viennese waltz
The tears streaming down my face after Andy’s waltz might be the best occupational hazard yet. Never underestimate the cheesy power of a recovering addict’s dance dedicated to his teenage daughter.
You’ll find Annie’s DWTS recaps, hidden gems, and exit interviews at ew.com/dwts.