Entertainment Weekly

Stay Connected


Advertise With Us

Learn More

Skip to content


To Be Sung Underwater review

Posted on

YOU CAN GO HOME AGAIN Tom McNeal's novel

To Be Sung Underwater

Current Status:
In Season
Little, Brown and Company

We gave it a B

Fortysomething L.A. film editor Judith Whitman’s life seems like a model of modern bourgeois comfort. But she finds herself foundering in her work and her marriage — and increasingly drawn back to the formative love affair of her Nebraska youth. McNeal’s writing vacillates between Cormac McCarthy’s muscular, squinty-eyed prose style and a goopier Bridges of Madison County-esque romanticism; the transitions can be jarring. Eventually, though, To Be Sung Underwater finds its stride: Even if its characters are archetypes (the cornpone-wise farm boy, the brittle Ivy League urbanite), they’re ones we come to care about. B

See all of this week’s reviews