Entertainment Weekly

Stay Connected

Subscribe

Advertise With Us

Learn More

Skip to content

Article

What's the saddest song ever?

Posted on

Anyone who?s ever lost a pet, a girlfriend, a job—or just had a really crap day—has their go-to Sad Song. You know, the one you put on repeat while you lie splayed on the kitchen floor, in the dark, slowly soaking the linoleum with your salty, salty tears. Now, a British scientist, Dr. Harry Witchel, has officially catalogued and ranked these songs according to their ?tune trigger quotient? and announced his findings of the Saddest Songs Ever.

According to Dr. Witchel?s formula, which measures the listener?s heart rate, respitory response, and skin temperature, the all-time saddest song is? the Verve?s devastating 1997 dirge ?The Drugs Don?t Work. (Though commonly misperceived as a song about recreational narcotics, it?s actually a tribute to singer Richard Ashcroft?s dying father. How?s that for sad?). The runners-up on this (admittedly very Anglocentric) list? Robbie Williams? ?Angels? and Elton John?s ?Sorry Seems to Be the Hardest Word.?

Americans undoubtedly have their own opinions; surely, many of us would choose from among the following: The Beatles? ?Yesterday,? Eric Clapton?s ?Tears In Heaven,? Jeff Buckley?s version of Leonard Cohen?s ?Hallelujah,? U2?s ?With or Without You?, Roy Orbison?s ?Crying,? R.E.M.?s ?Everybody Hurts?? and, for whatever reason, every classic wedding song with which the newly married choose to start their lives together (why is that?): Sinead?s ?Nothing Compares 2 U,? the Righteous Brothers? ?Unchained Melody,? Whitney?s ?I Will Always Love You.?

Just by checking my iTunes playlist, I see I am something of a veil-of-tears aficionado; in my top plays: Elliott Smith (well anything of his, really, but especially ?Angeles? and ?Fond Farewell to a Friend?), the Kinks? ?I Go to Sleep,? ? Antony & the Johnsons? ?For Today I am a Boy,? Bloc Party?s ?Tulips,? Bright Eyes? ?Land Locked Blues,? Cat Power?s ?Where Is My Love,? Modest Mouse?s, ?Bankrupt on Selling,? Love?s ?Always See Your Face,? Neil Young?s ?Only Love Can Break Your Heart? (and the St. Etienne cover too, for when I?m feeling Euro), Ratatat?s ?Everest,? Skeeter Davis? ?The End of the World,? Beck?s ?Lost Cause,? Sufjan Stevens? ?To Be Alone With You?? man. I?m starting to think I might actually need some serious meds.

Still, I know I?m barely scratching the surface of Sad. There are artists, from Boyz II Men to Bette Midler, that I haven?t even touched. For now, let?s just say the whole Smiths catalogue is implicitly included.

Comments