Today, Nigel and Fox finally announced the reason for all these big-time changes: Instead of dancing with each other, the season’s top 10 contestants will dance with a rotating, as-yet-unannounced all-star roster of SYTYCD alumni. Boom.
What does this mean? Well, in the YAY! column, it gives the show a desperately needed booster shot of new energy precisely when it was beginning to look and feel kinda tired and creaky. Long-time SYTYCD fans can delight in the return of old favorites — I’m personally pulling for the return of season 2’s Ivan, season 3’s Pasha, season 4’s Katee, and season 5’s Janette. And with only 10 contestants matched each week with a highly talented partner, the caliber of dancing in general by all rights should Grand Jeté over all previous six seasons. (Hat tip to fellow SYTYCD expert Kate Ward for the ballet reference.)
In the hrmmmm column, however… I’m left wondering if the show is stealing away one of its essential delights: Watching a partnership blossom between two untested dancers, like Ivan and Allison on season 2, Katee and Joshua on season 4, or Ashleigh and Jakob on last fall’s wobbly season 6. And in a funny way, SYTYCD has now positioned itself as a kind of inverse of its rival Dancing With the Stars — the experts are the stars now, making it that much harder for the contestants to grab that spotlight.
Still, all told, these changes have me far more keyed-up for the next season of SYTYCD this summer (which premieres Thursday, May 27) than I am for the uninspired dirge that’s quickly taking hold of sister show American Idol. But what say you, P-Dubs? Do all these changes make you keen again for So You Think You Can Dance? And which SYTYCD alums do you most want to see return?