Tim Stack
June 12, 2009 AT 04:00 AM EDT

Style report card

Broadway’s big night brought out some fashion do’s and some major don’ts. We grade the looks.

Ann Hathaway
Looking elegant in Oscar de la Renta at the June 7 awards in NYC, Hathaway — now on stage herself in Twelfth Night — deserves a standing ovation. A

Susan Sarandon
Fresh from her cougar-ific turn in the SNL ”Mother-lover” short, the 62-year-old (!) makes us love her even more in a revealing (but classy) black gown. B+

Lauren Graham
We adore the Guys and Dolls (and Gilmore Girls) star, but the emerald shade feels off. Even the lower bow seems to be attempting a dress escape. C

Carrie Fisher
Help her, Obi-Wan — you’re her only hope! Seriously, a Jedi robe would be preferable to this bizarre ensemble. The (fashion) force is definitely not with her. F

You May Like