Entertainment Weekly


Stay Connected


Advertise With Us

Learn More

Skip to content


Your favorite heartbreaking songs

A sampling of some of your picks for the most wrenching songs ever, from ”Fake Plastic Trees,” to ”Tears in Heaven”

Posted on

On EW.com’s Music Mix blog, we recently asked you to choose the all-time most wrenching songs. The response was huge: almost 2,000 comments. Here are just a few of your picks. And to see EW’s own list of the top 50, go to music-mix.ew.com/heartbreak.

Bonnie Raitt ”I Can’t Make You Love Me”
Reader Comment: ”She sings it like the man just walked out the door a moment before!” — tom

Radiohead ”Fake Plastic Trees”
Reader Comment: ”If this doesn’t make you emotional, then you have no soul.” — Mike

John Mayer ”Dreaming With a Broken Heart”
Reader Comment: ”I thought it was about someone leaving and the other person having to deal with that. But then I realized it’s about having someone die and having to wake up every day knowing they aren’t there anymore.” — Jenn

George Jones ”He Stopped Loving Her Today”
Reader Comment: ”A guy is faithful to a love not returned, all the way to his death! It doesn’t get sadder!” — Larry

Warren Zevon ”Keep Me in Your Heart”
Reader Comment: ”Nothing is sadder than a dying man with cancer writing his farewell song. Absolutely heart-wrenching lyrics.” — JR

Sinéad O’Connor ”Nothing Compares 2 U”
Reader Comment: ”Maybe it is just because I was in the middle of a breakup when it was popular, but I get choked up when I hear it.” — Jeannie

Eric Clapton ”Tears in Heaven”
Reader Comment: ”As a parent, it brings tears to my eyes and makes me want to hug my kids.” — Sparko

Jeff Buckley ”Hallelujah”
Reader Comment:‘I have yet to listen to it without crying. It’s the combination of a beautiful song, beautifully sung, and knowing what happened to Buckley.” — Miranda

Christina Aguilera ”Hurt”
Reader Comment: ”It really reminds me of my stepdad, who I never got to thank for all the great things he did for me. Ah, here come the tears.” — smn

The Beatles ”Eleanor Rigby”
Reader Comment: ”It searches beyond a broken heart to the profound existential angst of loneliness, a universal experience. It kills me every time.” — jaime47

Johnny Cash ”Hurt”
Reader Comment: ”It was released right before his wife died. He died not long after. I don’t recall anyone being able to listen to that song without ending up a blubbering mess. Brings tears to my eyes just thinking about it.” — Big Don